In 1921, a ferry crossing the Ébrié Lagoon in Côte d’Ivoire capsized. The accident gave rise to what appeared to be an ordinary legal dispute, but the resulting decision by the Tribunal des conflits redrew the boundary between public and private law in France. The Bac d’Eloka ruling laid the foundations for a distinction that has since become central: that between administrative public services and industrial and commercial public services.
Why the Bac d’Eloka ruling cannot be reduced to the privatization of public services
The Tribunal des conflits did not remove a public activity from administrative law and place it entirely under private law. The decision’s scope is narrower than this interpretation suggests.
The Tribunal held that the colony of Côte d’Ivoire, by operating a fee-paying transport service under conditions comparable to those of a private shipowner, fell within the jurisdiction of the ordinary courts for disputes relating to damage caused to users. It did not create a uniform private-law regime applicable to the service as a whole. The case brief on the Bac d’Eloka ruling sets out the precise circumstances of the decision and the actual scope of the reasoning behind it.
The general categories and criteria for identifying an industrial and commercial public service (SPIC) were clarified much later, notably in the 1956 Union syndicale des industries aéronautiques ruling. The 1921 decision opened a breach; it did not build the entire structure.

SPICs and private law: the exceptions created by the distinction
You might think that a SPIC operates entirely under private law, with the ordinary courts having jurisdiction over all disputes. In reality, jurisdiction is divided.
Organizational acts remain administrative
The Compagnie Air France v. Barbier ruling, handed down by the Tribunal des conflits on January 15, 1968, established a corrective principle. Certain acts relating to the organization of the service remain administrative acts, even within a SPIC. For example, internal regulations setting the terms of employment for flight crew may fall within the jurisdiction of the administrative courts.
This division means that a single service can give rise to two types of litigation, handled by two separate court systems. The boundary drawn in 1921 is therefore not a straight line.
Staff status: a legal patchwork
Ordinary SPIC employees are generally governed by employment law and fall within the jurisdiction of the ordinary courts. Two categories are exceptions:
- The service director, who is considered a public employee regardless of the form of their contract because they participate directly in the delivery of the public service.
- The public accountant, who is subject to public accounting rules and falls within the jurisdiction of the administrative courts for disputes relating to their duties.
- Any employee who, without holding the title of director, performs the service’s actual management functions, under subsequent case law.
As a result, within the same SPIC, the director and a technician do not fall under the jurisdiction of the same court. This complexity stems directly from the distinction introduced by the Bac d’Eloka ruling.
Classifying a service as a SPIC or SPA: the criteria courts still use
How can you tell whether a public service is industrial and commercial or administrative? Case law has established three main criteria, which courts apply cumulatively:
- The purpose of the service: does it produce goods or provide services comparable to those offered by a private business?
- The source of its funding: is the service funded mainly by user fees or by taxes and public subsidies?
- Its organization and operation: is it managed like a private business (commercial accounting, private-law employees)?
A service funded mainly by taxes will generally be classified as an administrative public service, even if it resembles a commercial activity. Funding often carries more weight than the service’s purpose in determining its classification.
The division of jurisdiction has been clarified for entire sectors. Wastewater services, for example, have been the subject of specific rulings to determine whether they fall within the jurisdiction of the administrative or ordinary courts. Each new sector-specific classification extends the logic set in motion in 1921.

The current significance of the Bac d’Eloka ruling in administrative law
More than a century after the decision, the SPA/SPIC distinction remains a cornerstone of French administrative law teaching and practice. It determines jurisdiction, staff status, the contractual rules applicable to users, and the law of liability.
Recent decisions show that the classification and its consequences continue to be debated before the courts. The Tribunal des conflits regularly intervenes to resolve jurisdictional questions when the nature of a service is unclear.
The ruling did not privatize part of the public service in the sense that the administration lost all control over these activities. Instead, it introduced a more nuanced division of rules and courts, requiring each service to be assessed on a case-by-case basis. The court with jurisdiction depends on the nature of the act, not just the nature of the service.
A user injured on a municipal public transport service does not apply to the same court as a resident challenging a building permit. This division of jurisdiction, the result of more than a century of case law, traces its origins to the opening created by the 1921 decision.



